Democratic Hub
About Us
Tour
FAQ
Signup
Login
  
Home
Forums
Pages
Issues
Laws
Elections
Arguments
Events
Government
U.S.
World
Welcome to our New Political Community - Take a Quick Tour of our Features including our Discussion Forums custom designed for U.S. politics. SIGN UP today to join in the discussion.
Forums > All Posts > Mental Health...do you really know anything about it?
  • Forums
  • Categories
  • All Posts
  • Forum Rules
  • FAQ\Help
Displaying all 5 Forum Posts

You must be logged in to reply to a post.
2011-01-16 09:02 PM
Square Photo
LLBarry
Beverly, MA
Posts: 299
Today I read a headline, "Lawmakers: Close look needed at mental health issues." See article. My post isn't really about what the article is about. But it got me thinking about how society really doesn't understand mental health issues and what brings them about or triggers people can be looking for. Do you know much about it? Should their be classes to parents and students so people might be able to see signs and help people before its too late?
2011-01-17 09:40 PM

sbfriedman
Denton, TX
Posts: 931
Tricky question. Yes, people should be aware of REAL mental health disorders, the signs, and the proper treatments. But, at the same time, over-educating the public can lead to paranoia, self-doubt, and can turn us all in to potential pharmacological guinea pigs. It's like those commercials, "Do you wake up tired?? Do you get upset easily?? Well, then you could have ________. You should try _________. Side effects are: __________________,_________________,___________,________________,and __________________.

A lot of people go through this world with some kind of disorder, whether it be an acute personality disorder, some kind of OCD, ADD, ADHD, off again on again depression, etc. The list is endless. But, my question is, are these really disorders that need to be treated? Or, are they just a part of life? I feel we are too quick to medicate because, well life is messy and we don't like to see the uglier sides of it. So, as the well-oiled machine that are society has become, mental health issues scare us and make us sad. The easy answer is medication, risky medication at that.

I'll jump off my soap box in just one more second. Let's say you are the one with a "mental health disorder". The more that we research and categorize, the more that that is an actual possibility. What if "they" or "the collective we" decide that the particular disorder you have is one that you can't control yourself, like extreme OCD for instance? Should you be locked up, drugged up and forgotten about?

My point is that it's a terrifying thing to let people start paying too much attention to "mental health disorders". I agree that it is a field that should be looked into for the very unhealthy. But there is too much wiggle room in there for profit. Profit from drugs, profit from therapy, etc. People's opinions on "crazy" or "mentally-handicapped" should be kept at a very strict, hard to obtain level for the true "mentally-ill".

Then again, I may have read Aldous Huxley's, "Brave New World" one too many times. ""A gramme is better than a damn," said Lenina mechanically from behind her hands. "I wish I had my soma!" "
2011-01-19 03:24 PM
Square Main Photo
indianacarnie
Jeffersonville, IN
Posts: 77
For a big segment of our population "A gramme is better than a damn" already. But I do agree with you about being very careful with mental health issues. We cant forget Stalinist(and afterwards) Russia here. "If you dont agree with us, the majority, then something must be wrong with you".
2011-08-10 10:08 AM
Square Main Photo
Hafar
Not Selected

Account Frozen

Posts: 30
sbfriedman Wrote: Tricky question. Yes, people should be aware of REAL mental health disorders, the signs, and the proper treatments. But, at the same time, over-educating the public can lead to paranoia, self-doubt, and can turn us all in to potential pharmacological guinea pigs. It's like those commercials, "Do you wake up tired?? Do you get upset easily?? Well, then you could have ________. You should try _________. Side effects are: __________________,_________________,___________,________________,and __________________.

A lot of people go through this world with some kind of disorder, whether it be an acute personality disorder, some kind of OCD, ADD, ADHD, off again on again depression, etc. The list is endless. But, my question is, are these really disorders that need to be treated? Or, are they just a part of life? I feel we are too quick to medicate because, well life is messy and we don't like to see the uglier sides of it. So, as the well-oiled machine that are society has become, mental health issues scare us and make us sad. The easy answer is medication, risky medication at that.

I'll jump off my soap box in just one more second. Let's say you are the one with a "mental health disorder". The more that we research and categorize, the more that that is an actual possibility. What if "they" or "the collective we" decide that the particular disorder you have is one that you can't control yourself, like extreme OCD for instance? Should you be locked up, drugged up and forgotten about?

My point is that it's a terrifying thing to let people start paying too much attention to "mental health disorders". I agree that it is a field that should be looked into for the very unhealthy. But there is too much wiggle room in there for profit. Profit from drugs, profit from therapy, etc. People's opinions on "crazy" or "mentally-handicapped" should be kept at a very strict, hard to obtain level for the true "mentally-ill".

Then again, I may have read Aldous Huxley's, "Brave New World" one too many times. ""A gramme is better than a damn," said Lenina mechanically from behind her hands. "I wish I had my soma!" "

Most people do not have mental disorders. Personaity disorders are never acute while some cute people have them. Mental disorders are not normal and they should be treated. In fact they are very painful and can be life threatening. The issue is far more complicated then the context its being offered here.   We have used the term disorder to describe many behaviors seen in children such as conduct disorder and Oppositional defiant disorder but that applies mainly to children. The old PMS is being brought back and give me a break thats not a disorder. Two disorders that are widely used with little real evidence is autism and ADHD. The reason for the label is to get paid by an insurance co. Sadly the child gets labeled with a disorder that could be total crap.
2011-08-14 09:44 PM
Square Main Photo
mccabe49
Not Selected
Posts: 5
Hafar while  I agree with you that many mental health disorders can be threatening I disagree with your assessment of autism';  I also disagree with you regarding personality disorders not being acutel an example I will give you is Borderline Personality DO; it can be quite acute and can involve serious self harm (cutters..ect..)
You must be logged in to reply to a post.


 
About Us
Contact Us
FAQ
Advertise
Links
Login
Sign Up
  


� Copyright 2009-2012 Democratic Hub. All Rights Reserved.
Terms & Conditions | Privacy Policy


OBAMA ACCOMPLISHMENTS - REPUBLICAN DIVORCES - REPUBLICAN INFIDELITY & AFFAIRS - REPUBLICAN SCANDALS & CONTROVERSIES